It is known above all for the colour and clarity of its water, an intense blue owed partly to the white limestone of its bed. The village of Bacalar sits on its western shore.

As with most bodies of water across the peninsula, Bacalar draws its supply from below, by underground rivers that surface here and there in open pools called cenotes; the porous limestone of the peninsula leaves almost no room for lakes, which makes Bacalar the exception. The lake holds a large population of stromatolites, rounded, cauliflower-like formations built up by very ancient forms of life that survive in only a few places around the globe.